All posts
arrow-narrow-right
Lifestyle Goals
arrow-narrow-right
Current article

Is Vaping Worse Than Smoking Cigarettes or Tobacco? Here's What Experts Say

Published on
December 11, 2024
Is Vaping Worse Than Smoking Cigarettes or Tobacco? Here's What Experts Say
Author
Can I use essential oils internally?

While some essential oils can be used internally, it's crucial to consult with a qualified professional before doing so. Only certain oils are safe for internal use, and it's essential to follow recommended guidelines to prevent any adverse effects.

Impact-Site-Verification: 70d5c0ba-33f2-44f1-9951-38c895f4527e

Are all essential oils pure?

Not all essential oils are created equal. It's essential to look for pure essential oils that are free from synthetic additives or dilution. Quality is crucial when it comes to the best essential oils for your needs.

How do I choose the best essential oil brand?

When selecting the best essential oil brand, consider factors such as the brand’s reputation, the quality of its oils, whether it offers therapeutic-grade products and reviews from other users.

This page contains affiliate links. As affiliates, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases. Your support helps us create content like this.

Vaping and smoking are two prevalent methods of nicotine consumption, each with distinct mechanisms and health impacts. Smoking involves burning tobacco, producing harmful tar, and carbon monoxide, which are linked to severe health issues like lung cancer and heart disease. On the other hand, vaping heats a liquid containing nicotine, flavorings, and other chemicals to create vapor. While often perceived as a safer alternative, vaping still carries significant health risks. So, let’s take a deep dive at what experts and their research have to say about the two.

The Addictive Properties of Vaping and Smoking

When comparing the addictive properties of vaping and smoking, it's essential to understand that both methods deliver nicotine, a highly addictive substance. Traditional cigarettes are known for their strong addictive potential due to the rapid delivery of nicotine to the brain, which reinforces smoking behavior.

Research indicates that while e-cigarettes might be perceived as less addictive, they can still lead to significant nicotine dependence. This study found that e-cigarettes are less addictive than traditional cigarettes but more addictive than nicotine gums. However, the ease of use and appealing flavors of e-cigarettes may lead to higher consumption, particularly among younger users.

Another study highlighted by Yale Medicine revealed that teens who vape are more likely to develop a stronger addiction to nicotine compared to those who smoke, due to the higher nicotine concentrations in some e-liquids. This suggests that while the delivery method differs, the addictive nature of nicotine remains a significant concern for both vaping and smoking.

Is Vaping Safe or Not?

The safety of vaping is a contentious topic, with ongoing research highlighting both potential benefits and risks. While vaping is generally considered less harmful than smoking traditional cigarettes, it is not without its dangers.

E-cigarettes do not contain tobacco and thus avoid the harmful tar and many of the carcinogens present in cigarette smoke. This has led some health professionals to consider vaping a safer alternative for current smokers looking to quit (source). Do note, though, that this doesn’t mean that vaping is completely safe.

Studies have shown that vaping can cause significant health issues. For instance, the American Lung Association points out that vaping can lead to lung damage, respiratory issues, and cardiovascular problems which we’ll be discussing later on. Additionally, a study by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) reports that e-cigarettes can cause damage to blood vessels and increase the risk of heart disease.

Another 2022 study showed exercise stress test results among people who vape, smoke, and those who do not. Individuals in the vaping group consistently performed worse than those in the control group but slightly better than those in the smoking group. From what I can see, vaping also takes a toll on your physical health.

It’s important to note that studies have yet to determine the long-term effects of vaping. The relatively recent introduction of e-cigarettes means that comprehensive long-term studies are still in progress. Current evidence suggests that while vaping might be less harmful than smoking, it is not without significant risks, particularly for non-smokers and younger individuals who might be drawn to vaping due to its flavors and perceived safety.

Heart Risks of Smoking and Vaping

When comparing the heart risks associated with vaping and smoking, research consistently shows that both practices pose significant cardiovascular dangers, though the extent and nature of these risks can differ.

Smoking traditional cigarettes is well-documented to severely impact heart health, contributing to conditions such as coronary artery disease, heart attacks, and strokes. The harmful chemicals in cigarette smoke, including tar and carbon monoxide, damage the cardiovascular system by increasing blood pressure, reducing oxygen supply, and promoting plaque buildup in arteries.

Vaping, while often marketed as a safer alternative, also presents substantial heart risks. A study published in the Journal of the American College of Cardiology found that e-cigarette users are more likely to develop heart failure compared to non-users. Another study highlighted by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) revealed that chronic e-cigarette use impairs blood vessel function, potentially increasing the risk of cardiovascular diseases.

Furthermore, research from the University of Kansas Medical Center found that e-cigarette users were 56% more likely to have a heart attack and 30% more likely to suffer a stroke compared to non-users (source). These findings underscore that while vaping might avoid some of the harmful byproducts of combustion found in traditional smoking, it still poses significant risks to heart health.

Respiratory Risks of Smoking and E-Cigarettes

When examining the respiratory risks associated with vaping and smoking, it is clear that both practices can lead to significant respiratory health issues, though the mechanisms and severity may differ.

Traditional cigarette smoking is well-known for its severe impact on respiratory health. It causes chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), lung cancer, and chronic bronchitis. The combustion of tobacco produces harmful chemicals like tar and carbon monoxide, which damage lung tissue and impair respiratory function.

Vaping, while sometimes perceived as a safer alternative, also poses serious respiratory risks. A study published in the American Journal of Preventive Medicine found that e-cigarette use was associated with an increased risk of developing chronic lung diseases such as asthma, bronchitis, and emphysema. This study indicated that the risk of developing lung disease was significantly higher among e-cigarette users compared to non-users.

Moreover, research from the British Medical Journal (BMJ) highlighted that e-cigarette users reported increased susceptibility to respiratory infections and delayed recovery from such infections. This is likely due to the inhalation of harmful chemicals like formaldehyde, acrolein, and other volatile organic compounds found in e-cigarette vapor, which can irritate and damage the respiratory tract.

Additionally, a systematic review in npj Primary Care Respiratory Medicine found that vaping leads to short-term respiratory changes, including increased airway resistance and breathing difficulty. These findings suggest that while vaping might avoid some of the direct combustion-related harms of smoking, it still poses significant risks to respiratory health.

Another study in 2020 suggested that current e-cigarette users have about a 40% greater chance of developing a respiratory condition compared to those who don’t vape or smoke.

Can Vaping Also Cause Cancer?

E-cigarettes do not contain tobacco, which is the primary source of many carcinogens in traditional cigarettes. However, they do contain nicotine and other chemicals that can pose cancer risks. A study published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences found that nicotine and nicotine-derived nitrosamines in e-cigarette vapor can cause DNA damage and inhibit DNA repair in lung and bladder cells, potentially leading to cancer.

Further research by the University of Southern California (USC) showed that e-cigarette users develop some of the same cancer-related molecular changes in oral tissue as cigarette smokers. These changes include alterations in gene expression that are linked to cancer development.

Moreover, a study highlighted by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) reports that certain chemicals found in e-cigarette vapor, such as formaldehyde and acrolein, are known carcinogens and can damage DNA, potentially leading to cancer.

While no human cancer cases directly linked to e-cigarette use have been conclusively documented, the presence of carcinogenic substances in e-cigarette vapor and the observed molecular changes in users suggest a potential risk. The long-term effects of vaping are still being studied, but current evidence indicates that it is not without significant cancer risks.

Long-Term Health Effects of Vaping and Smoking

Smoking

Smoking traditional cigarettes has been extensively studied and is known to cause a wide range of severe health issues:

  • Cancer: Smoking is a leading cause of various cancers, including lung, mouth, throat, esophagus, and bladder cancers.
  • Respiratory Diseases: Smoking causes chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), chronic bronchitis, and emphysema.
  • Cardiovascular Diseases: Smoking increases the risk of heart disease, stroke, and peripheral artery disease due to the harmful effects of tar and other chemicals on blood vessels.
  • Weaker Immune Function: Smoking weakens the immune system which makes smokers more susceptible to infections.
  • Reproductive Issues: Smoking can lead to infertility, complications during pregnancy, and adverse effects on fetal development.

Vaping

While vaping is generally considered less harmful than smoking, it is not without significant long-term health risks:

  • Respiratory Issues: Vaping is associated with increased risks of respiratory diseases like asthma, bronchitis, and potential development of conditions similar to COPD (source).
  • Cardiovascular Problems: Studies indicate that vaping can impair blood vessel function and increase the risk of heart disease.
  • Potential Carcinogenic Effects: Although vaping lacks many of the carcinogens found in tobacco smoke, it still involves exposure to potentially harmful chemicals like formaldehyde and acrolein, which can damage DNA and possibly lead to cancer (source).
  • Nicotine Addiction: Both smoking and vaping deliver nicotine, which is highly addictive and can lead to long-term dependence and associated health issues (source).
  • Impact on Brain Development: In younger individuals, nicotine exposure from vaping can harm brain development, affecting learning, memory, and attention (source).

Is It Safer to Use Vape to Quit Smoking?

Vaping is often promoted as a less harmful alternative to smoking, and some studies support its use as a smoking cessation aid. For instance, a study published in the New England Journal of Medicine found that e-cigarettes were more effective than nicotine replacement therapy (NRT) in helping smokers quit. However, vaping is not without risks, including potential respiratory and cardiovascular issues, as well as the risk of continued nicotine addiction.

Better Alternatives for Quitting Smoking

Several alternatives to vaping are considered safer and effective for smoking cessation:

  1. Nicotine Replacement Therapy (NRT): Provides controlled doses of nicotine through patches, gum, lozenges, nasal sprays, or inhalers to reduce withdrawal symptoms without the harmful chemicals in cigarettes.
  2. Prescription Medications such as Bupropion (Zyban) and Varenicline (Chantix): These medications help reduce nicotine cravings and withdrawal symptoms by targeting brain receptors involved in addiction.
  3. Behavioral Therapy: Offers counseling and psychological support to change smoking-related behaviors and thought patterns, enhancing the effectiveness of other cessation methods.
  4. Combination Therapy: Involves using multiple cessation methods, such as combining NRT with prescription medications and behavioral therapy, to increase the likelihood of successfully quitting smoking.
  5. Support Programs: Provide resources, counseling, and community support through quitlines, online programs, and apps to help individuals stay motivated and manage cravings.

The Bottom Line

Now, while we do have some studies lined up that provide valuable insights into the potential risks and benefits of vaping, there is a pressing need for more comprehensive and long-term research. Until more solid evidence is available, it is crucial to approach vaping with caution and rely on established smoking cessation methods that have a proven track record of safety and effectiveness.

The comparison between vaping and smoking reveals that while vaping may present fewer immediate risks than smoking traditional cigarettes, it is not without significant health concerns. Both practices deliver nicotine, leading to addiction and various health issues. Smoking is well-documented to cause severe respiratory, cardiovascular, and cancer-related diseases. Vaping, although lacking many of the harmful byproducts of combustion found in smoking, still poses risks to respiratory and cardiovascular health and potentially carries carcinogenic effects.

For those seeking to quit smoking, vaping might offer a less harmful alternative, but it is not the safest option. Established methods such as nicotine replacement therapy (NRT), prescription medications, behavioral therapy, and support programs are generally recommended due to their proven effectiveness and safety profiles.

Recommended Products for Smoking Cessation and Alternatives to Vaping

For those looking to quit smoking or vaping, these products can aid in managing cravings and provide healthier alternatives:

Nicotine Stop Smoking Aid Clear Patches

Nicotine patches offer a steady release of nicotine to help reduce withdrawal symptoms and manage cravings, making the quitting process smoother.

up&up Coated Nicotine 2mg Gum Stop Smoking Aid

Nicotine gum provides a fast-acting way to curb nicotine cravings, helping to ease the transition away from smoking or vaping.

EZFly: TSA-Accepted Oral Fixation Flavored Air Device

This non-nicotine device offers flavored air as an alternative to vaping, helping to satisfy oral fixation without harmful chemicals or smoke.

Tazo Tea

Alternatively, drinking herbal teas like Tazo can be a soothing alternative to smoking or vaping, offering a calming ritual that helps reduce anxiety and cravings.